09 May 2011 / 10:10

Turkish Health Sector Eyes Balkan Market

Altin Raxhimi
Istanbul

The main entrance hall of the Acibadem Maslak Hospital in Istanbul’s European quarter is crammed with relatives of Turkish pop singer Ibrahim Tatlises, who is being treated here for gunshot wounds, and security guards, anxious to keep the press at bay.

"The treatment here is good," says 76-year-old Milena Stamatovic of her heart surgery at the Acibadem Maslak Hospital (Photo: Altin Raxhimi)

Oblivious to the hubbub on the floors below, 76-year-old Milena Stamatovic, a housewife from a village outside Belgrade, recovers following an operation on her heart. Stamatovic is far from lonely here; she is just one of fourteen patients on the fourth floor ward who hail from Serbia.

Turkey has emerged as a key health tourist destination for many from the Balkans, as health service provision deteriorated following the collapse of communism and during the conflicts of the 1990s.

In turn, Turkish state-run and private hospitals have aggressively courted Balkan patients, particularly Istanbul, with its hundreds of private hospitals.

This has been particularly true of countries that have strong cultural ties with Turkey, such as Albania, Kosovo and Macedonia.

The Turkish health ministry estimates around 58,000 international patients were treated in its hospitals in 2010 alone.

This influx of foreign patients has been matched with the rapid expansion of the private health sector over the past ten years. Today, a third of Turkey’s hospitals are privately run, says Rusen Yildirim, chairman of Turkey’s Health Tourism Business Council who has co-authored an as yet unpublished study on Turkish health tourism with the country’s health ministry.

Patients from the Balkans

• Universal Hospital Group says it treats about 350 patients from Albanian-speaking areas in the Balkans.

• Acibadem says it treats a further 600 patients from the Balkans each year.

• At least 350 patients from Albania are treated in Medical Park hospitals, according to Albaturk, a Turkish health consulting company in Tirana.

NB: The Turkish health authorities do not keep statistics on Balkan patients treated in Turkey

Of those 58,000 international patients, the majority are German nationals. However, more than 1000 come from Balkan countries, according to figures from a few of the Istanbul-based hospital groups.

Daniel Benevisti, a spokesman for the Acibadem hospital group, believes this trend will continue – particularly once the global economy recovers.

“We have seen numbers double both from international patients, and those specifically from the Balkans,” says Benevisti.

At her office not far from the Acibadem Maslak Hospital, Teuta Turku-Gocmen would agree with Benevisti, as she returns to her desk after seeing off a couple from Vushtrri, a northern Kosovan town, who have used her services for fertility treatment at the German Hospital of Istanbul.

Turku-Gocmen is a translator and referral agent for patients, who has been hired by the German Hospital to deal with ethnic Albanians from the Balkans. She acts as a referral service for Albanian-speakers who are unable, or unwilling, to undergo various medical procedures back home - about two dozen patients from Kosovo and Albania monthly.

And booming health tourism in Turkey has spawned an industry of its own back in the Balkans.

In Albania’s capital Tirana, Albert and Ilirjana Zyfi, both aged 42, wait in a residential apartment building on one of the Albanian capital’s busiest streets. The Zyfis are anxious to hear if Sefak Onbasiouglu, an Istanbul-trained doctor, will advise them to pursue fertility treatment in Turkey, as they wish to have a second child now their son is a teenager.

Business opportunities

Onbasioglu, an Istanbul-based orthopaedist, set up the Tirana office in 2005 sensing a lucrative business opportunity in identifying and treating patients from Albania in Turkey for a host of problems, including prosthetic surgeries and fertility treatments.

He says he sends at least 30 patients there every month, including Istanbul’s private Medical Park hospital, for check-ups, medical operations and, a recent trend, plastic surgery.

Ankara-born Attila Gursel, 42, says the same. Once employed as an architect by a Turkish developer in Tirana, Gursel soon turned his hand to sending patients to Turkey. Before giving up his referral work to concentrate on his regular day job as a manager for Turkish Airline in Tirana, he says he sent Albanian patients to Turkey “in their hundreds”.

The referral business that sprang up somewhat haphazardly with Gursel and others is now far more organised, with major health groups establishing agencies and front offices across the region.

Large Turkish hospital groups like Acibadem and Medical Park have established, or are in the process of setting up, front offices in Tirana and Skopje to refer patients from those countries to their hospital chains in Turkey.

Foreign nationals treated in Turkey*

2008 - 56,000

2009 - 72,000

2010 - 52,000 (analysts blame the dip in 2010 on the economic downturn)

Four out of five international patients seek eye and dental treatments in Turkey.

The rest come for oncology, heart and bone treatments, plus plastic surgeries.

Source: Turkish Foreign Economic Relations Board and Ministry of Health of Turkey

Acibadem, Universal Hospital Group (UHG), which owns the German Hospital of Istanbul, and Medical Park are among the dozen or so groups that cater to international patients, making Turkey a regional hospital hub for the Middle East, Turkic republics of the former Soviet Union and the Balkans, as well as many from western Europe, notably among Turkish migrant communities there, says Rusen Yildirim, who heads the health sector group of the Turkish Foreign Economic Relations Board (DEIK), a lobbying group for Turkish businessmen.

Yildrim says Turkish private hospitals built up their services for foreign patients over the past 20 years and is now worth up to around 140 million euros annually.

The Turkish health sector has, he says, targeted three key groups: the US, following Obama’s health care reform programme, western Europeans looking to escape long waiting lists and neighbouring countries, including the Balkans.

“Globalisation helped us see where we are, compared to other medical centres in the world, when our economy opened up. Getting international patients is prestigious for Turkish hospitals, and raises their domestic profile as well,” says Yildirim.

The Turkish health tourism industry is worth up to €140 million annually says Rusen Yildirim of the Health Tourism Business Council (Photo: Altin Raxhimi)

“Several private hospital chains have developed oncology departments, and many come from the Balkans go to such centres because it is a short distance… this has developed especially with the private hospitals,” Yildirim says. “In the 90s, they saw this as a business opportunity.”

These hospitals offer what has been the staple of health tourism, including advanced cancer operations, hip or knee replacements, eye laser treatment and aesthetic, cosmetic surgeries. The treatments are better, faster or cheaper than foreign patients can access at home.

“Our aim is to serve people five hours away from here,” confirms Benevisti, the Acibadem spokesman, as he settles into a cushioned chair at the Kitchenette, a trendy, western pastry shop on Istanbul’s noisy Taksim Square.

Advanced technology

He says Turkey’s private investment in health has led to the introduction of advanced technology that that is prohibitively costly in Balkan countries. Some of the private hospital groups, like Acibadem, offer advanced medical treatment, like ‘gamma knife’ surgery for brain tumours.

Besides, Turkey is competitive on prices, offering many treatments around a third cheaper than in EU member states.

 “Albanians believe that corruption in their health system is high,” says Zamira Sinoimeri, a former deputy health minister of Tirana who now works for the World Health Organization. “So, for many, rather than paying money in bribes and not get good treatment, they would [prefer to] pay for a private service and get it.”

But it is not just the private sector that is treating Balkan patients. Ankara has treated hundreds of patients from Albania in its state hospitals since the 1990s. These treatments were paid for by the Albanian state.

The Acibadem hospital has struck agreements with most governments of former Yugoslavia who pay to treat patients in need of delicate cancer or heart operations, like Milena Stamatovic.

The fact most Balkan citizens don’t need visit visas to go to Turkey, and the national air carrier Turkish Airlines connects all Balkan capitals to Istanbul, has also helped make Turkey the health destination of choice for Balkan patients.

When Turku-Gocmen began working at the German Hospital in Istanbul five years ago, she said she was reluctant to abandon her hairdressing business in a nearby part of town.

She had moved from the Adriatic coast 15 years ago, and intended to keep her hairdressing business inside the hospital and work with Albanian patients on the side.

Yet, she found herself so overwhelmed that she now works only as a referral agent and translator for patients from Albania, Kosovo and Macedonia.

EU market challenge?

Some believe that the lifting of visa requirements for Balkan states by the EU - only Kosovo remains behind the strict Schengen visa wall - will reduce Turkey’s booming health tourist market as travel to the West becomes cheaper and easier.

The German Hospital in central Istanbul treats numerous Albanian-speaking patients, including fertility care and cosmetic surgery (Photo: Universal Health Group)

“It will not always stay this way for Turkish hospitals,” says Onbasioglu. “There are new private hospitals in Albania and Macedonia and the service is slowly improving. But it is too early to say whether the visa lifting has had any effect at all.”

And there seems little evidence of any downturn in the number of Balkan patients coming to Turkey for treatment just yet.

Turku-Gocmen flashes me her Blackberry with a sideways look. Many of the Albanian patients at the German Hospital come through her contacts in Albania and elsewhere – her husband is Kosovo Albanian.

“One for breasts; one for belly; one for nose… two for belly and breasts,” she says. These are potential customers for cosmetic surgery her contact in Albania had found.

Omer, an engineer with a hospital in Skopje of Macedonia, is sending his son for eye surgery at the World Eye Center in Istanbul.

“The treatment is much better there than the treatment I can get here in Skopje,” he says. “I want to be on the safe side.”

This article was produced as part of the Balkan Fellowship for Journalistic Excellence Alumni Initiative, established and supported by the Robert Bosch Stiftung and ERSTE Foundation.

Fellow Bio

/en/file/show/altin-raxhimi.jpg

Altin Raxhimi

Altin Raxhimi from Tirana, Albania, is an experienced journalist currently working freelance from Albania for a host of English-language publications, including BIRN, www.reportingproject.net, Inter-Press Service and The Chicago Tribune

/en/file/show/Turkey-Header-403x80.png

Turkey and the Balkans

The re-emergence of Turkey as a growing economic, political and religious power in the Balkans is the subject of the latest Balkan Fellowship for Journalistic Excellence Alumni Initiative project.

Meet the Journalists

/en/file/show/altin-raxhimi.jpg

Altin Raxhimi

Altin Raxhimi from Tirana, Albania, is an experienced journalist currently working freelance from Albania for a host of English-language publications, including BIRN, www.reportingproject.net, Inter-Press Service and The Chicago Tribune

/en/file/show/lavdim-hamidi.jpg

Lavdim Hamidi

Lavdim Hamidi was born in 1982 in Trnovac and is currently living and working in Kosovo. He is an experienced economics reporter and works for the daily newspaper, Zeri

/en/file/show/gjergj-erebara.jpg

Gjergj Erebara

Gjergj Erebara was born in 1979 in Tirana, Albania. He has been specialized in economic reporting and currently works as journalist in “Shqip” daily published in Tirana and BalkanInsight.com publication.

/en/file/show/aleksandra-stankovic.jpg

Aleksandra Stankovic

Aleksandra Stankovic was born in 1973 in Pirot, Serbia. She graduated in 1997 in Arabic language and literature from the Faculty of philology at Belgrade University

/en/file/show/yana-buhrer-tavanier.jpg

Yana Buhrer Tavanier

Yana Buhrer Tavanier is a freelance journalist and a human rights activist based in Sofia, Bulgaria. Previously she was editor of weekly Capital, and worked as a journalist for Tema magazine and daily Dnevnik.

Alumni Stories

/en/file/show/turkish-health-sector-eyes-balkan-market-1.jpg
09 May 2011 / 10:10

Turkish Health Sector Eyes Balkan Market

Altin Raxhimi

The main entrance hall of the Acibadem Maslak Hospital in Istanbul’s European quarter is crammed with relatives of Turkish pop singer Ibrahim Tatlises, who is being treated here for gunshot wounds, and security guards, anxious to keep the press at bay.

21 Apr 2011 / 11:11

Davutoglu: ‘I’m Not a Neo-Ottoman’

Compiled by Altin Raxhimi

Q&A with Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu

/en/file/show/ethnicity-numbers-and-identity-in-istanbul-1.jpg
24 Mar 2011 / 12:20

Ethnicity, Numbers and Identity in Istanbul

Altin Raxhimi

Salahetting Bolukbas’s 21-year-old niece stands on a glass bar serving hunks of Bosnian burek in the main thoroughfare of Bayrampasa, a suburb on the European, western side of Istanbul.

/en/file/show/ethnicity-numbers-and-identity-in-istanbul-1.jpg
22 Mar 2011 / 10:10

Albanians, Leeks and are Bulgarian Turks Emotionally Cold?

Altin Raxhimi

I have been researching relations between Turkey and the Balkans of late, ahead of my trip to Turkey this week. It’s been fun, well mostly, to discover what the average Turk might think of Albanians, Bosnians and Bulgarians.

/en/file/show/Macedonia-Turkey-The-Ties-That-Bind-1-thumb.jpg
14 Feb 2011 / 10:10

Macedonia-Turkey: The Ties That Bind

Darko Duridanski (link)

While Ankara maintains close diplomatic relations with Skopje, cemented by their shared political enmity toward Greece, Turkey must step carefully when it comes to inter-ethnic disputes within ‘the heart of the Balkans’.

/en/file/show/Turkey-s-Balkan-Shopping-Spree-thumb.jpg
15 Dec 2010 / 10:00

Turkey’s Balkan Shopping Spree

Lavdim Hamidi

Ankara is investing in strategic sectors in the Balkans in order to increase its economic and political influence, but what’s on Turkey’s must-buy list?

/en/file/show/Economics-Override-History-for-Belgrade-and-Ankara-thumb.jpg
15 Dec 2010 / 09:00

Economics Override History for Belgrade and Ankara

Aleksandra Stankovic

After a long period of distant, often frosty relations, Turkey and Serbia appear to be finally warming to each other. But will the Serbian people put aside historic grievances dating back to the Ottoman Empire and welcome Ankara’s Balkan renaissance?

/en/file/show/Albanian-Muslims-grapple-with-religious-identity-thumb.jpg
15 Dec 2010 / 08:55

Albanian Muslims grapple with religious identity

Altin Raxhimi

A Turkish brand of Islam now dominates the country’s religious institutions, as local Muslims struggle to find their own spiritual path.

/en/file/show/Albanians-questions-negative-view-of-Ottomans-thumb.jpg
15 Dec 2010 / 08:50

Albanians question "negative" view of Ottomans

Gjergj Erebara

Aggressive invader or friendly administration? The portrayal of the Ottoman Empire in Albania’s history books remains the subject of fierce debate for Albanians and Turks alike.

/en/file/show/Ottoman-past-haunts-Turkey-s-Balkan-image-thumb.jpg
15 Dec 2010 / 08:45

Ottoman past haunts Turkey's Balkan image

Marcus Tanner

Ankara must be careful projecting itself as a player in a region where the word “Turk” still carries a good deal of historical baggage.

/en/file/show/Turkey-EU-row-stymies-Serb-export-deal-thumb.jpg
15 Dec 2010 / 08:40

Turkey-EU row stymies Serb export deal

Aleksandra Stankovic

A 3m euro beef export deal between Serbia’s impoverished Sandzak region and Turkey has been blocked because of a trade dispute between Ankara and the EU.

/en/file/show/Balkans-stability-impossible-without-Serbia-thumb.jpg
15 Dec 2010 / 08:35

‘Balkans stability impossible without Serbia’

Aleksandra Stankovic

Turkey’s former ambassador to Belgrade says relations with Serbia are at an all time high, but warns his successor’s to-do list is long and difficult. He gives Balkans Insight his end of term report.